Ref Watch: Nottingham Forest Penalty Controversy and FA Cup Handball Decisions – Dermot Gallagher and Stephen Warnock’s Views

In a controversial weekend of Premier League and FA Cup action, former referee Dermot Gallagher has weighed in on some key decisions that have sparked debate among fans and pundits alike.

Nottingham Forest found themselves at the center of attention after being denied three potential penalties in their crucial clash with Everton. Ashley Young was at the heart of the controversy, with accusations of kicking Giovanni Reyna, committing a handball, and fouling Callum Hudson-Odoi. Gallagher, along with former player Stephen Warnock, analyzed the incidents and gave their verdicts.

Gallagher believed that the third penalty appeal for Forest should have been given, despite the on-field referee and VAR deciding otherwise. Warnock also pointed out Young’s reaction, suggesting that the player knew he had committed a foul.

The post-match statements from Nottingham Forest, questioning the integrity of the officials, drew criticism from pundits like Jamie Carragher and Gary Neville. The suggestion that VAR Stuart Atwell is a Luton fan was also met with skepticism, with Sky Sports News’ Rob Dorsett explaining the intricacies of referee appointments.

In the FA Cup semi-final between Coventry and Manchester United, another contentious handball decision arose, with Gallagher expressing doubts over the penalty awarded to Coventry. The debate over handball incidents continued in the match between Manchester City and Chelsea, with Gallagher questioning whether the referee should have been sent to the screen for a potential penalty call against Jack Grealish.

Overall, the weekend’s events have once again highlighted the complexities and controversies surrounding refereeing decisions in football, with experts like Gallagher and Warnock offering their insights and opinions on the matter.